← All projects
09 · MCD dissertation · 2026

Whether a space is public is settled by whether you can sit in it without spending anything.

Title
Governance and Control in the Public Realm
Sites
Liverpool ONE, Royal Albert Dock, Church Street
Fieldwork
12 structured observation visits over 10 days
Periods
Weekday morning, afternoon and evening, weekend afternoon
Method
Observation at three fixed points per site, behavioural mapping, photographic recording
Submitted
September 2026
Governance and control in the public realm

How management practices shape everyday social use of public spaces in Liverpool.

Three city-centre spaces were compared under three governance models, using a consistent observational tool at three fixed points per site, supported by behavioural mapping, photographic recording and documentary analysis of each management regime.

Governance worked through the terms of use rather than visible enforcement. Nobody was observed being asked to leave, and camera provision was broadly comparable across all three sites, yet recorded behaviour differed sharply.

Privately managed estate, 250-year leasehold

Liverpool ONE

About 80 people seated on the Sugar House Steps, the most generous provision recorded. No protest or petitioning observed.

Council-owned highway with a BID overlay

Church Street

Free stone benches around street trees, about 30 seated. The only site where protest, petitioning, begging and informal selling occurred.

Private estate management, Grade I listed

Royal Albert Dock

A few benches on Hartley Quay, with the colonnades given over to restaurant tables. No takeaway consumption in the main dock area.

Two dimensions of publicness

Provision for comfort and tolerance of activity varied independently. No site achieved both.

The three sites placed on two dimensions of publicness.
Three implications for practice

Whether a square becomes somewhere people linger depends as much on the management regime as on the paving.

  • Where public realm is delivered through long-term leases or estate management contracts, a minimum provision of free seating could be made a condition of those agreements.
  • Arrangements that license informal activity, such as Church Street’s pre-booked pitch system, offer a middle path between unregulated use and exclusion.
  • Temporary closure of publicly accessible elements warrants notification, since those elements are often presented as public benefit at the approval stage.